OnlineMasterofLegalStudies.com is owned by 2U, LLC, parent company of edX. Our goal is to help learners make confident, informed decisions about their education and career. Some programs shown here are offered by universities that partner with 2U, for which 2U provides marketing and operational support and receives compensation. Other programs shown may be paid advertisements from third parties. Both types of programs are identified with the word AD or Advertisement. We aim to keep information current and accurate. Learn more about edX and our partners.


Types of Alternative Dispute Resolution

When used appropriately, alternative dispute resolution can help parties in a dispute work toward flexible and creative solutions, and some processes may reduce stress or keep a dispute private. This guide explains the main types of ADR (arbitration, case evaluation, collaborative law, conflict coaching, mediation, mini-trials and parenting coordination) and how they differ in who makes the final decision.

There are various types of ADR, and sometimes different names are used for similar processes. Court and provider guidance describes several characteristics that many ADR processes share, although how far each applies depends on the specific process and the rules that govern it:

  • Informality – ADR is generally less formal than courtroom proceedings, though formality varies: arbitration, for example, is still a structured process in which an arbitrator decides based on the facts, evidence and law, according to FINRA. Depending on the process, that informality can appeal to people who may be intimidated, overwhelmed or exhausted by more formal judicial systems and processes. A less formal process can also help speed up proceedings and reduce cost, and the Department of Justice describes its own EEO mediation program as private, confidential, faster and cost-effective.
  • Equity and Fairness – ADR cases are decided by a neutral third party or negotiated by disputants themselves, and some processes rely less on uniformly applied legal standards than a court does. Mediation, for example, resolves only the parties’ own dispute and does not create legal precedent, according to Maryland courts, while arbitration applies the facts, evidence and law. Whether an outcome is fair therefore depends on how the particular process works and the rules that govern it.
  • Participation and Communication – Successful ADR depends on participation and communication between disputants. By facilitating dialogue, many ADR processes can provide more opportunities for reconciliation and more flexibility in designing creative settlements. In mediation, for example, the parties themselves decide whether to settle, and a court can require them to attend mediation but cannot require them to agree, according to Maryland courts.

If you’re thinking about becoming an ADR practitioner, there are different types of ADR you can choose to practice. This list, though not exhaustive, is a good place to start if you wish to learn more about the types of ADR.

At a glance, the processes differ in who makes the final decision and whether the outcome binds. Details vary by program and jurisdiction, and each process is explained, with sources, in the sections below:

  • Arbitration – the arbitrator decides. An award is binding in the American Arbitration Association’s process; in nonbinding arbitration, a party may be able to seek review of the award.
  • Case evaluation – the parties decide. The neutral evaluator gives a non-binding assessment and cannot impose a settlement.
  • Collaborative law – the parties decide, with their lawyers’ help. The lawyers must withdraw if a contested court proceeding begins.
  • Conflict coaching – the person being coached decides. The coach does not decide the dispute.
  • Mediation – the parties decide. The outcome does not bind until they reach and sign a settlement agreement.
  • Mini-trial – the parties’ representatives with settlement authority decide. The results are generally nonbinding unless the parties agree otherwise.
  • Parenting coordination – depends on the jurisdiction and the court order. In Massachusetts, a coordinator’s binding decisions require the parents’ written agreement incorporated into a court order, and the court keeps authority over custody, parenting time and support.

University of California, Davis

Ad

Strategic Negotiations

Become a strategic negotiator, in professional and personal contexts.

Arbitration

In arbitration, two parties present evidence to a neutral third party (an arbitrator) who has the ability to make a legally binding decision, or “award,” that is enforceable in court, as the American Arbitration Association (AAA) describes it. In nonbinding arbitration, the decision is advisory. In Minnesota courts, for example, a party may request an appeal of a nonbinding award within a certain amount of time, while a binding award is final. Arbitration is used to resolve commercial disputes and consumer and employment matters and can be voluntary or mandatory (as mandated by the terms of a contract in which the parties agree to resolve existing or future disputes through arbitration). The AAA notes that a case can proceed without an arbitration clause only if all parties agree.

Relevant Links:

  • Roster criteria for the AAA National Roster of Arbitrators (American Arbitration Association)

Case Evaluation

Also known as “early neutral evaluation,” or ENE, case evaluation is a process in which a neutral third party examines evidence and provides their evaluation of the case. Case evaluators advise disputants on the strengths and weaknesses of their evidence and positions, which the parties may use to help reach a mutually agreeable resolution. The Northern District of California’s ENE program is one example: the evaluator hosts an informal session in which each side presents its evidence and arguments, then privately writes an evaluation. The evaluation is non-binding, the evaluator has no power to impose a settlement, and communications from the session ordinarily are not disclosed to the assigned trial judge.

Relevant Links:

Collaborative Law

In litigation, both parties relinquish their decision-making to a judge or jury. Collaborative law processes, on the other hand, are voluntary alternatives to going to court in which parties and their lawyers commit to settlement negotiation from the outset. According to the International Academy of Collaborative Professionals (IACP), participants sign a participation agreement, openly share the facts relevant to the issues and negotiate in good faith toward a settlement all can accept. Each party has a lawyer, but those lawyers must withdraw if a contested court proceeding begins. Parties may also add supporting professionals, such as mental health and financial specialists, who likewise step back if litigation starts. The parties themselves reach the final agreement; a judge or jury does not decide the outcome. The IACP also reports that the Uniform Collaborative Law Act had been enacted in 28 jurisdictions in the United States as of September 2026.

Conflict Coaching

Conflict coaching is focused on helping an individual build the skills to handle a dispute and manage conflict more effectively on their own. At Michigan State University, for example, a coach works one-on-one with a person involved in a conflict. The coach does not decide the outcome, and the person keeps control over how the conflict is resolved. The university’s coaches may also offer suggestions for how to move forward toward resolution. Because the coach does not decide the dispute, coaching differs from mediation, in which a neutral helps the parties negotiate.

Mediation

In mediation, the third party presiding over the dispute has no power to impose a resolution, as FINRA describes it. Mediators guide disputants toward a mutually agreeable settlement, but the final decision is left to the parties themselves, and a mediated outcome is not binding until the parties reach and sign a settlement agreement. In the Department of Justice’s EEO mediation program, for example, the parties record the terms of a successful mediation in a detailed written agreement that both sign. Whether a signed settlement can be enforced as a contract depends on the law that applies to the dispute.

Mini-Trial

A mini-trial is a hearing where attorneys for each party present a summarized version of their case to representatives from each side who have authority to settle the dispute, as the Southern District of Texas describes in its ADR overview. A judge or other third party may preside, but that is optional, and a presiding neutral can help with settlement talks if the parties ask. The difference between mediation and a mini-trial is that the people deciding whether to settle are the parties’ own representatives, who hear the presentations directly. If the parties use a neutral adviser and the representatives fail to settle, the adviser may issue an advisory opinion, which Minnesota courts describe as non-binding unless the parties agree otherwise and sign a written settlement. Indiana Rule 4.4 offers a court-ordered example: people who can make settlement decisions attend, attorneys summarize their clients’ positions, the proceeding is treated as settlement negotiation and kept confidential, and the results are nonbinding unless the parties agree otherwise.

Parenting Coordination

Parenting coordination is a child-focused ADR process in which a third party assists high conflict parents to work out problems in implementing a court-issued parenting plan. Parenting coordinators (PCs) are either appointed by a court or hired by parents who wish to reduce child-related conflicts, and the details depend on the jurisdiction and on the court order or agreement that creates the role. In Massachusetts, Standing Order 1-17 describes parenting coordination as a process in which parents work with a court-appointed provider to reduce the effects of conflict on their children. Under that order, parents may agree in writing to use a coordinator, and the agreement is enforceable only if it is incorporated into a court order or judgment. A judge may also appoint a coordinator without an agreement if the court finds it serves the children’s best interests and the parents have not carried out the parenting plan or their conflict is harming the children, but the court cannot require a parent to pay for a coordinator without that parent’s consent. Where there are credible domestic violence allegations or findings, the court must give each party a chance to consult an attorney or domestic violence advocate before accepting an agreement, and it cannot appoint a coordinator over a party’s objection.

The Massachusetts order also limits what a coordinator can do. A coordinator may make binding decisions only with the parents’ express written agreement incorporated into an order or judgment, and cannot facilitate a change in legal custody. An agreement that modifies an existing order is enforceable only if the court approves and incorporates it. The court keeps exclusive authority over fundamental issues of custody, parenting time and support, even when parents have agreed to binding decision-making. Although PCs usually cannot change court-ordered guidelines such as custody or visitation, the main function of the PC is to resolve co-parenting disputes and reduce the effect of parental conflict on children.

If a career in alternative dispute resolution sounds interesting to you, read our guide on how to become a mediator to learn more about mediation qualifications and requirements. If you want to advance your knowledge of the legal system and the skills to help opposing parties settle disputes outside of court, you might consider a master’s in dispute resolution degree.

The London School of Economics and Political Science

Ad

Negotiation Programme

Learn the practical skills and theoretical insight to increase your negotiating capability, confidence, and success.

Information last updated: October 2026